The Autumn Sun

Passing Through wrote:

PURPLE SECTOR

Glyn Schofield

Got put out of the race half way around. We nearly ended up on the Kenso.

Schofield fined $1000 for "making forcible contact" with J McDonald.

horlicks wrote:

Passing Through wrote:

PURPLE SECTOR

Glyn Schofield

Got put out of the race half way around. We nearly ended up on the Kenso.

Schofield fined $1000 for "making forcible contact" with J McDonald.

After the race, with his fist

Mr Grieves wrote:

Visually impressive win but yes, it was a narrow win over Fundamentalist, who Amphitrite beat easily, who in turn was beaten easily by Mystic Journey. If they're smart they'll go Rosehill Guineas/Derby with TAS

Fundamentalist was beaten by Nakeeta Jane who was beaten by Fundamentalist.

reductio ad absurdum

Agree totally with Mr Grieves. Not knocking TAS. He is top 3yo and looks better suited to 2000m plus but he would not get close to Winx.

Pretty clear from last 8 days that there is very little between fundamentalist and nakeeta Jane.

Prejudice is an emotional attachment to ignorance.
DiEM25 for the world.

I don’t want to see Winx beat TAS by 10 lengths.
He isn’t even the best 3yo
Two fillies are well ahead of him.
Yes he won but the $26 shot was 3 lengths behind him when he started his march and finished 3 lengths behind him. Nearly made up identical ground as they went stupid in front.
Nakeeta Jane nearly won backing up on an old path
Fundamentalist couldn’t win in melb so was sent on easier path up there.
He ran home very well and is a good horse but spare me this Winx or even beat 3yo stuff.
Not in the same league

Horse owner, breeder, punter.

Winx and TAS should meet.

With all the Weir story demoralising racing, the industry needs to showcase good battles.

In saying that though, Winx would be coasting by his side around the turn, and it would be evident very quickly why Winx is the greatest ever.

The colt is good, but if they ran side by side over 2000, she would crush him.

Great win, needs to go to the derby.
Winx would beat him by 10 hard held.

the miz
v'landwick the king of spin

bph2510 wrote:

Thank you. Visually great win.
The fact it took every bit of 1600 to beat fundamentalist answers the best 3yo theory.
Don’t worry about racing Winx. She wouldn’t get out of 3rd gear.
I have him 3rd best 3yo
Behind Mystic journey and Arcadia queen

Sunlight says hi.

You know? What I seen Saturday, has really left me wondering? Who might be better? Winx is still at the top of her game right NOW!! Amazing to think/ see that but I can't see we're she has gone backwards? And this colt just might give her a shake?? Hard call. But I'm sure all the press and radio hosts, will default to the self proclaimed genius in Dominic burn for his analysis that he says is the only way!

His next race will definitely be the Rosehill Guineas, there is no open age race for him really? Besides running in the Ranvet on the same day.. which no three year old would ever do.

He will go to whichever race Winx isn’t in.

This space has been intentionally left blank

https://www.unnamedwebsite.com.au/news/australian-racing/winx-a-hindrance-for-the-autumn-sun/507287

Basically they still have no idea what to do.

No offence but regardless of Winx going to the George Ryder - why would you possibly send TAS there? On yesterdays race are you really thinking you should drop him down in distance after that?

He wouldn't beat Le Romain home in it, let alone Winx. He looks to be every bit a 2000m horse.

No reason why he won't handle mooney V . Most horses do

Speediskey wrote:

His next race will definitely be the Rosehill Guineas, there is no open age race for him really? Besides running in the Ranvet on the same day.. which no three year old would ever do.

Pretty sure Beau Zam sidestepped the Rosehill Guineas to take on his elders ?

reductio ad absurdum